Islamorada's Top Hotels and Resorts

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Alan Reid

Updated: 19 February 2024 · 3 min

Nestled in the center of the Florida Keys, Islamorada is often regarded as a paradise for those in pursuit of the perfect blend of relaxation and adventure. This string of islands is renowned not just for its breathtaking natural beauty, but also for the exquisite accommodations it offers. Among these, the hotels in Islamorada stand out as havens of comfort and luxury, promising an unforgettable experience to all who visit.

Choosing the right hotel in Islamorada can elevate your vacation from a simple getaway to an extraordinary journey of discovery. With options ranging from intimate boutique hotels to luxurious resorts, each lodging in Islamorada offers unique amenities tailored to fulfill your desires. Whether you're yearning for a serene retreat by the ocean, seeking thrilling water sports, or wishing to indulge in the local culinary delights, there's a hotel in Islamorada that caters to your every whim.

Insider tips and recommendations are invaluable when navigating the plethora of options available. Hotels in Islamorada are more than just places to stay; they are gateways to the rich culture and mesmerizing nature of the Florida Keys. By considering factors such as location, available amenities, and personal interests, visitors can ensure they select a hotel that not only meets but exceeds their expectations, making their stay in Islamorada truly magical.
Show more + Show less -

Our Top 6

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. The Moorings Village
2. Amara Cay Resort
3. Cheeca Lodge & Spa
4. Islander Resort
5. Casa Morada Hotel
6. Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina

Luxury Resorts and Hotels in Islamorada, Florida

Check Availability

Islamorada
Feb 28, 2026 - Mar 01, 2026

The Moorings Village

9.3

Good

(11 Reviews)

+ 180 photos
The Moorings Village offers an intimate glimpse into the luxury lifestyle of Islamorada with its private, lush surroundings and exquisite beachfront villas. Once a coconut plantation, this hotel radiates a sense of exclusivity and tranquility, allowing guests to indulge in the beauty of the Florida Keys in privacy. Each villa is uniquely designed, offering tailored experiences for guests, whether they seek a romantic hideaway or a splendid family oasis. With amenities such as a heated pool, tennis courts, and over a mile of pristine white sand beach, The Moorings Village is a sanctuary where luxury meets natural beauty.
Address: 123 Beach Rd
Rating: Good 9.3 (11 Reviews)
Rooms: 7
Price: From 459$

Amara Cay Resort

8.2

Good

(703 Reviews)

+ 226 photos
Amara Cay Resort integrates the laid-back vibe of the Florida Keys with family-oriented hospitality. This hotel offers a blend of relaxation and adventure, with amenities such as a heated pool, hammock-lined gardens, and a variety of water sports rentals available on-site. The rooms are spacious and feature modern decor, catering to families seeking both comfort and style. With a dedicated play area for kids and activities designed to entertain guests of all ages, Amara Cay Resort embodies the spirit of a family vacation that balances leisure with excitement.
Address: 80001 Overseas Highway
Rating: Good 8.2 (703 Reviews)
Rooms: 110
Price: From 266$

Family-Friendly Hotels in Islamorada, Florida

Choosing the right family-friendly hotel in Islamorada is crucial to ensuring a memorable and enjoyable vacation for all ages. These hotels in Islamorada are designed with families in mind, offering amenities and activities that cater to the young and the young at heart. From kid-friendly pools and water sports to spacious accommodations and family-oriented dining options, these hotels promise a stay that is as relaxing for the parents as it is exciting for the children. Discover the joy of a family vacation where every member finds something to love, all set against the stunning backdrop of Islamorada's natural beauty.

Cheeca Lodge & Spa

8.6

Good

(1126 Reviews)

+ 260 photos
Cheeca Lodge & Spa stands as a beacon of luxury in Islamorada, offering guests an escape into elegance and comfort. This iconic resort sprawls over 27 acres, featuring lush tropical gardens and a private, sandy beach that beckons visitors to unwind in its serene embrace. With amenities such as a nine-hole par 3 golf course, a world-class spa, and oceanfront dining, Cheeca Lodge seamlessly blends relaxation with opulence. The rooms and suites are designed with an eye for sophisticated comfort, offering breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean or the resort's manicured grounds. Family-friendly yet also perfect for romantic retreats, Cheeca Lodge & Spa represents the pinnacle of luxury living in Islamorada.
Address: 81801 Overseas Highway, Mile Marker 82
Rating: Good 8.6 (1126 Reviews)
Rooms: 242
Price: From 639$

Islander Resort

8.5

Good

(1499 Reviews)

+ 159 photos
Islander Resort is a treasure trove of family fun, offering spacious accommodations and a host of activities that engage children and adults alike. The resort's oceanfront location provides direct access to the beach, where families can enjoy sunny days building sandcastles or exploring the shallow waters. With two saltwater pools, a splash pad, and on-site dining options that offer kid-friendly menus, Islander Resort ensures a comfortable and entertaining stay for families. The resort's focus on creating unforgettable family memories makes it a standout choice for those visiting Islamorada with loved ones.
Address: 82100 Overseas Highway
Rating: Good 8.5 (1499 Reviews)
Rooms: 114
Price: From 204$

Casa Morada Hotel

9.0

Good

(78 Reviews)

+ 241 photos
Casa Morada seizes the essence of bespoke luxury, offering a tranquil and intimate experience for those who tread off the beaten path. This secluded hotel, exclusively for adults, focuses on providing a serene and intimate atmosphere, making it ideal for romantic getaways or tranquil solo adventures. The suites are individually decorated, mirroring the artistic and luxurious essence of Islamorada. With personalized services, a private island connected by a bridge offering yoga and spa services, and an infinity pool that overlooks the bay, Casa Morada invites guests to immerse themselves in a refined and peaceful encounter with the Florida Keys.
Address: 136 Madeira Road
Rating: Good 9.0 (78 Reviews)
Rooms: 16
Price: From 320$

Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina

8.0

Good

(1264 Reviews)

+ 252 photos
Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina is a paradise for families looking to soak up the sun and sea. With its iconic beachfront location, the resort offers an array of outdoor activities, including diving, fishing, and water sports, ensuring that adventure is always within reach. The rooms and suites are designed with a cozy, beachy feel, accommodating families of all sizes comfortably. The resort also boasts a lagoon-style pool and on-site dining options that cater to even the pickiest eaters, making it an ideal spot for families aiming for a worry-free vacation in Islamorada.
Address: 84001 Overseas Highway
Rating: Good 8.0 (1264 Reviews)
Rooms: 139
Price: From 180$